π Introduction
Ensuring stopPropagation()
works correctly in React applications is crucial when handling nested click events. Instead of checking if stopPropagation() was explicitly called, the best approach is to test its effectβwhether the event propagates or not.
This article explores:
β
The best approach to testing stopPropagation()
(checking event propagation).
β An alternative method using event mocking.
β Which method is better and when to use each approach.
π Best Approach: Testing the Effect of stopPropagation()
The recommended way to test stopPropagation()
is to wrap the tested component inside a parent <div>
with an onClick
handler and check whether the event reaches the parent.
Example: Testing Propagation Prevention
import { render, screen } from "@testing-library/react";
import userEvent from "@testing-library/user-event";
import { FormElementsList } from "@/components/FormElementsList";
it("stops propagation when an element is clicked", async () => {
const onOuterClick = jest.fn();
render(
<div onClick={onOuterClick}>
<FormElementsList elementsList={[{ name: "Text Input", type: "text", icon: <span>π</span> }]} />
</div>
);
const textInputElement = screen.getByText("Text Input");
await userEvent.click(textInputElement);
expect(onOuterClick).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(0); // Ensures event does not propagate
});
π Why This Works ?
The parent
<div>
has anonClick
handler (onOuterClick).If
stopPropagation()
is correctly applied insideFormElementsList
, clicking on an element should not trigger onOuterClick.The assertion
expect(onOuterClick).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(0)
ensures the event was stopped successfully.
π Alternative: Mocking stopPropagation()
If you need to directly verify that stopPropagation() was called, you can mock the event and track the function call.
Example: Mocking stopPropagation()
import { render, screen } from "@testing-library/react";
import { FormElementsList } from "@/components/FormElementsList";
it("calls stopPropagation when an element is clicked", async () => {
render(<FormElementsList elementsList={[{ name: "Text Input", type: "text", icon: <span>π</span> }]} />);
const textInputElement = screen.getByText("Text Input");
const event = new MouseEvent("click", { bubbles: true });
jest.spyOn(event, "stopPropagation");
textInputElement.dispatchEvent(event);
expect(event.stopPropagation).toHaveBeenCalled();
});
π Why This Works ?
jest.spyOn(event, "stopPropagation")
tracks whether the function is called.dispatchEvent(event)
manually triggers the click event.expect(event.stopPropagation).toHaveBeenCalled()
ensures stopPropagation() was executed.
π Which Method Should You Use?
Method | β Pros | β Cons |
---|---|---|
1. Testing Effect (Wrapper <div> ) |
Tests real user behavior | Doesnβt confirm stopPropagation() was explicitly called |
2. Mocking stopPropagation() |
Confirms stopPropagation() is called |
Tests implementation rather than behavior |
π Recommended Approach
Prioritize testing real behavior over implementation details for better maintainability!
π¬ Have you used different methods for testing event propagation? Share your thoughts in the comments!
Top comments (0)