1. Behavioral Analysis
a) Account Activity Patterns
- Login times and frequency (e.g., if someone typically logs in from New York at 9 AM but suddenly logs in from Manila at 3 AM)
- Number of proposals sent (e.g., sending 50 proposals in 1 hour is suspicious)
-
Time spent on each page (genuine users spend time reading, while bots move quickly)
b) Communication Style Monitoring
Message patterns and templates
Language consistency
-
Response timing Example: If a freelancer suddenly changes their writing style from professional English to broken English, it raises flags
c) Job Posting/Bidding Behaviors
Bid amounts (unusually low or high bids)
Copy-pasted proposals
Immediate responses to all job posts Example: A genuine freelancer takes time to craft unique proposals, while scammers often use identical messages
2. Machine Learning Systems
a) Automated Fraud Detection
def detect_suspicious_activity(user_data):
risk_score = 0
# Check login patterns
if user_data.login_country_changes > 3:
risk_score += 20
# Check proposal patterns
if user_data.proposals_per_hour > 10:
risk_score += 15
return risk_score > 30
b) Pattern Recognition
- Historical data analysis
- Behavior clustering
- Anomaly detection Example: System identifies patterns like multiple accounts sharing the same IP address or bank details
3. Profile Quality Checks
a) Portfolio Verification
- Image reverse search
- Code repository validation
-
Project timestamp verification Example: System checks if portfolio images are stolen from other websites
b) Skills Assessment Tests
Monitored test taking
Score pattern analysis
-
Time tracking during tests Example: If someone scores 100% in 2 minutes on a test that typically takes 30 minutes
c) Work History Validation
Client interaction verification
Payment history analysis
Project completion rates Example: A sudden spike in completed projects with minimal time spent raises flags
4. Additional Security Measures
a) Two-Factor Authentication (2FA)
function verify2FA(user, code) {
const storedCode = generateTOTP(user.secret);
const timeWindow = 30; // seconds
return {
isValid: code === storedCode,
expiresIn: timeWindow
};
}
b) IP Address Monitoring
- Geolocation tracking
- VPN detection
-
Login pattern analysis Example: Multiple accounts accessing from the same IP range
c) Device Fingerprinting
Browser characteristics
Screen resolution
Installed fonts
-
Hardware specifications Example: System creates unique device IDs to track suspicious patterns
d) Social Media Verification
Profile cross-referencing
Activity timeline verification
Connection analysis Example: LinkedIn profile showing 10 years of experience while the person claims to be 18
Real-World Implementation:
class AccountRiskAssessor:
def calculate_risk_score(self, account):
score = 0
# Location checks
if self.has_multiple_login_locations(account):
score += 25
# Communication patterns
if self.detect_template_messages(account):
score += 15
# Profile consistency
if not self.verify_portfolio_authenticity(account):
score += 30
# Bidding behavior
if self.analyze_bid_patterns(account):
score += 20
return score
def take_action(self, risk_score):
if risk_score > 75:
return "BLOCK_ACCOUNT"
elif risk_score > 50:
return "FLAG_FOR_REVIEW"
return "MONITOR"
These systems work together in real-time to create a robust security framework. For example:
1. A user logs in from a new location
2. System checks:
- Device fingerprint
- IP address
- Time of login
- Previous activity patterns ## 3. Risk score is calculated ## 4. Action is taken based on combined factors
This multi-layered approach helps Upwork maintain platform integrity while allowing legitimate users to work freely. The system continuously learns and adapts to new patterns, making it increasingly effective at detecting sophisticated scam attempts.
If you found this article helpful, consider following me for more technical deep dives. Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below!
Top comments (4)
Thank you
Thank you for your article.
👍
Perfect, this is very helpful for me.