Sospeter Mong'are

Posted on Jan 27

What Belongs in the Database vs. What Belongs in Application Code

#database #programming #beginners #tutorial

In software development, one of the key principles for building efficient, maintainable, and scalable systems is understanding where to place specific tasks—whether in the database or in the application code. The rule of thumb is simple: What can be done on the database should remain in the database, while what should be done using programming should be done in code.

This principle ensures that each component of your system is used for its strengths, leading to better performance, easier maintenance, and a more robust architecture. In this article, we’ll explore what tasks belong in the database, what tasks belong in code, and why this separation matters.

Why This Separation Matters

Before diving into the specifics, let’s understand why this separation is important:

Performance: Databases are optimized for data operations. Offloading tasks like filtering, sorting, and aggregating to the database improves performance.
Maintainability: Keeping data-related logic in the database and business logic in code makes the system easier to understand and maintain.
Scalability: Databases can handle large datasets and high query loads, while application code can scale horizontally.
Consistency: Database constraints and transactions ensure data consistency, reducing the risk of bugs or corruption.
Reusability: Database objects like stored procedures, views, and functions can be reused across multiple parts of the application.

What Should Be Done in the Database

Databases are designed to store, retrieve, and manipulate data efficiently. Tasks that involve large datasets, complex queries, or data integrity should be handled in the database. Here are some examples:

1. Data Validation and Constraints

Use database constraints like NOT NULL, UNIQUE, PRIMARY KEY, FOREIGN KEY, and CHECK to enforce data integrity.
Example: Ensure an email column is unique and not null directly in the database schema.

2. Complex Queries

Use SQL to perform complex joins, aggregations, filtering, and sorting.
Example: Calculate the total sales for each customer using a GROUP BY query instead of fetching all records and processing them in code.

3. Indexing

Create indexes on frequently queried columns to improve read performance.
Example: Add an index on a user_id column if it’s often used in WHERE clauses.

4. Stored Procedures and Functions

Use stored procedures or functions for reusable logic that operates on the database.
Example: A stored procedure to calculate the average order value for a customer.

5. Transactions

Use database transactions to ensure atomicity, consistency, isolation, and durability (ACID properties).
Example: Transfer funds between two accounts within a single transaction to ensure consistency.

6. Triggers

Use triggers to automate actions based on database events (e.g., updating a last_modified timestamp when a row is updated).

7. Data Partitioning and Sharding

Use database features to partition or shard large datasets for better performance and scalability.

What Should Be Done in Code

Programming languages are better suited for tasks that require complex logic, business rules, or integration with external systems. Here are some examples:

1. Business Logic

Implement business rules and workflows in code.
Example: Calculate discounts based on user loyalty or promotional rules.

2. Data Transformation

Transform data into a format suitable for presentation or external APIs.
Example: Convert a database result into a JSON response for a REST API.

3. Integration with External Systems

Handle interactions with third-party services, APIs, or external systems.
Example: Send an email notification when a user signs up.

4. User Interface Logic

Handle UI-related logic, such as form validation, dynamic content rendering, or user interactions.
Example: Validate a form input before submitting it to the database.

5. Error Handling and Logging

Implement custom error handling and logging mechanisms.
Example: Log errors to a file or monitoring system when a database query fails.

6. Caching

Use application-level caching (e.g., Redis, Memcached) to reduce database load.
Example: Cache frequently accessed data like product details.

7. Security

Implement application-level security measures, such as authentication, authorization, and input sanitization.
Example: Hash passwords before storing them in the database.

Example Scenario

Let’s look at a practical example to illustrate this principle.

Task: Calculate the total revenue for a specific product category.

Database Responsibility:

Write a SQL query to sum the revenue for the category:

  SELECT SUM(price * quantity) AS total_revenue
  FROM orders
  WHERE category_id = ?;

Application Responsibility:

Fetch the result from the database and format it for display:

  def get_category_revenue(category_id):
      query = "SELECT SUM(price * quantity) AS total_revenue FROM orders WHERE category_id = ?"
      result = db.execute(query, (category_id,)).fetchone()
      return f"Total Revenue: ${result['total_revenue']}"

When to Bend the Rule

While this principle is generally a good guideline, there are exceptions:

Prototyping: For quick prototypes, it might be easier to handle everything in code.
ORM Limitations: If using an ORM, some database-level optimizations might be harder to implement.
Legacy Systems: In legacy systems, it might not be feasible to move logic to the database immediately.

In such cases, aim to refactor over time to align with this principle.

Conclusion

Understanding what belongs in the database and what belongs in code is crucial for building efficient, maintainable, and scalable systems. By leveraging the strengths of both databases and programming languages, you can create applications that perform well, are easy to maintain, and can grow with your needs.

Remember:

Database: Data storage, retrieval, integrity, and complex queries.
Code: Business logic, data transformation, external integrations, and user interface logic.

By following this principle, you’ll be well on your way to building robust and scalable software systems.

DEV Community