Lessons Learned: Overusing useMemo in React

Recently, while working on a React Native app for SWK, a local service provider, I came across the useMemo Hook for the first time. It seemed like a magical tool for optimizing performance by caching expensive computations. Excited about the possibilities, I started using it almost everywhere. However, I quickly realized that overusing useMemo can lead to unnecessary complexity without tangible benefits. Here's what I learned and how you can avoid the same mistakes.

What Is useMemo?

useMemo is a React Hook designed to optimize performance by caching the result of a computation. React recalculates this value only when its dependencies change. It's most useful for expensive calculations that might otherwise slow down your app. For instance:

const sortedItems = useMemo(() => {
  return items.sort((a, b) => a.value - b.value)
}, [items])

Here, the sortedItems variable is recalculated only when the items array changes, saving time during re-renders.

For a deeper dive into how useMemo works, check out the React official documentation.

Performance Analysis with useMemo

Before adding useMemo to your code, ask yourself: Is the computation expensive enough to warrant optimization? To find out, you can use tools like the React Profiler. Here's how:

1. Profile Without useMemo: Use the Profiler in React DevTools to measure rendering times.
2. Identify Bottlenecks: Look for components that take a long time to render or frequently re-render.
3. Add useMemo: Apply it to optimize specific expensive calculations.
4. Compare Performance: Profile again to confirm improvements.

Example:

const expensiveComputation = useMemo(() => {
  return performComplexCalculation(data)
}, [data])

By testing before and after adding useMemo, you can verify whether it has a meaningful impact.

When to Use useMemo vs. Other Tools

useMemo works well for caching derived values, but it's not the only optimization tool in React:

• React.memo: Use this to memoize entire components, preventing unnecessary re-renders when props haven't changed. Learn more about React.memo.
• State Management with Zustand: Zustand offers a lightweight and intuitive approach to managing shared state, reducing the need for derived state or excessive memoization. It simplifies managing and updating global state without extra boilerplate.

Quick Tip: Reserve useMemo for expensive computations, while React.memo shines for optimizing component rendering. Combine these judiciously with efficient state management for the best results.

Avoiding Common Pitfalls

Here are some common mistakes to watch out for:

• Memoizing Simple Calculations: Avoid using useMemo for lightweight tasks like:

  const hasData = useMemo(() => data.length > 0, [data])

This doesn't save much processing power and adds complexity.

• Unstable Dependencies: Ensure your dependency array contains stable references; otherwise, React recalculates unnecessarily.

  const result = useMemo(() => compute(items), [items])

For more on how dependency arrays work, see this React guide on Hooks.

Edge Cases and Code Examples

When useMemo Helps:

Memoization shines when working with computationally expensive operations, like filtering or sorting large datasets:

const filteredData = useMemo(
  () => data.filter((item) => item.active).sort((a, b) => a.value - b.value),
  [data]
)

In this case, memoizing avoids recalculating the result on every render unless data changes. This can lead to noticeable performance improvements, especially with large arrays or complex operations.

When useMemo Hurts:

For trivial computations, like this:

const isLoading = useMemo(() => !data.length, [data])

useMemo adds unnecessary overhead. Simple logic or derived values, like !data.length, can be directly defined without memoization.

Better approach:

const isLoading = !data.length

Using useMemo in such cases complicates your code without measurable benefits.

For more in-depth examples and scenarios, check out this Telerik guide on useMemo.

---

Final Thoughts

useMemo is a precision tool, not a catch-all solution. Always start by profiling your app, and remember that clarity and maintainability should come first. When used correctly, useMemo can significantly enhance performance, but misuse can just as easily detract from it.

Comments

[Tom Österlund]

I somehow never used useMemo in production, though I've been building with React since over 4 years 😬

[Dean (딘)]

Felt that way too until a couple of months ago :D My experience with React is almost the same as yours and when I saw the useMemo hook been used in the React Native app I'm working on, I at first thought of it as a replacement of const :D