Gatsby vs Next.js in 2021

In this episode of Syntax, Scott and Wes talk about Gatsby vs Next. A lot has changed in the last year — what are the differences, and do the recommendations from Syntax 120 still hold true?

Sanity - Sponsor

Sanity.io is a real-time headless CMS with a fully customizable Content Studio built in React. Get a Sanity powered site up and running in minutes at sanity.io/create. Get an awesome supercharged free developer plan on sanity.io/syntax.

Sentry - Sponsor

If you want to know what’s happening with your errors, track them with Sentry. Sentry is open-source error tracking that helps developers monitor and fix crashes in real time. Cut your time on error resolution from five hours to five minutes. It works with any language and integrates with dozens of other services. Syntax listeners can get two months for free by visiting Sentry.io and using the coupon code “tastytreat”.

Show Notes

03:34 - Server-rendered

• Both do server rendered
• Gatsby is gone at build time
• Next is done at build and on deploy

05:26 - Static generation

• getStaticProps()
• getServerSideProps()

08:25 - Re-rendering pages

• Gatsby can be re-rendered and re-deployed - any CMS lets you do this on only the pages that changed.
• Gatsby-cloud
• Next.js has the revalidate flag that will re-render when stale

18:54 - Data management

• Gatsby has a built in GraphQL API feature with
• Next.js has nothing - it’s not their problem. Use Apollo, or SWR, React Query, or redux, or whatever you want.

23:16 - Client-side data

• Neither do anything, next.

26:33 - Dynamic Pages

• List of 100 shoes, each one gets a page
• List of four types of shoes: basketball, runners, casual, bowling, etc.
• List of 10 colors: each color gets its own page.
• List of 12 sizes, each size gets its own page.
• Now it gets complicated when you do this:
  • Show me basketball shoes, in red, in size 5
  • 600 pages minimum
  • What about size 6+7?
  • Then you get into having to fetch data on the client side - but all your data is in GraphQL?!
  • The queries are different!
• Gatsby will get “Hosted GraphQL”: https://twitter.com/kylemathews/status/1252803849775009794

30:41 - Routing

• Neither do nested routing still
• Both do folder based wrapper

34:50 - Hosting

• Anywhere

35:54 - Images

• Compression/resize
• Lazy loading
• SVG
• Blur up
• Next 10 released first revision of Next.js image
  • It’s not as good as Gatbsy-image
  • Must specify width and height, whereas gatsby has fixed and fluid
  • Compression
  • No blur up
  • Yes lazy loading
  • both don’t support gifs
  • Gatbsy requires annoying GraphQL query OR another plugin like MDX to do it
    • Not for long! https://twitter.com/ascorbic/status/1320770231657238529
  • Next.js is just 

Episode source